How much does storm motion change helicity on the same wind profile?
Changing storm motion changes the origin from which a hodograph’s signed area is measured. The underlying wind profile can stay fixed while storm-relative helicity changes.
Start with How do you combine positive and negative helicity contributions?.
| Motion (m/s) | Relative lower endpoint | Relative upper endpoint | Signed contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| (0,0) | (0,10) | (10,10) | +100 m²/s² |
| (0,5) | (0,5) | (10,5) | +50 m²/s² |
Set up the experiment
Hold the bottom and top winds at (0,10) and (10,10) m/s. Compare assumed storm motion (0,0) with (0,5) m/s. Predict which produces the larger positive segment contribution. Subtract each storm vector from both endpoints. Evaluating u₂v₁−u₁v₂ gives +100 and +50 m²/s². This one segment represents the chosen layer in the experiment.
Practice questions
- Use motion (0,10) m/s.
- Use motion (0,15) m/s.
- Why can the relative value change without a change in ground-relative shear?
Worked answers
Answer 1
The lower relative wind becomes zero and the segment contributes zero.
Answer 2
The relative v component is −5 m/s at both ends. The result is −50 m²/s².
Answer 3
The wind difference still uses the same endpoints. The signed helicity also depends on the endpoints’ positions relative to storm motion.
- The lower relative wind becomes zero and the segment contributes zero.
- The relative v component is −5 m/s at both ends. The result is −50 m²/s².
- The wind difference still uses the same endpoints. The signed helicity also depends on the endpoints’ positions relative to storm motion.