How many grid cells resolve a simulated supercell updraft?
Divide the physical width of an updraft by grid spacing to estimate how many nominal cells span it. Use a refinement comparison to examine whether its structure is resolved.
Start with How much memory does a three-dimensional supercell grid require?.
| Grid spacing | Updraft width | Nominal cells across |
|---|---|---|
| 1 km | 3 km | 3 |
| 250 m | 3 km | 12 |
| 125 m | 3 km | 24 |
Set up the experiment
Keep the updraft width fixed at 3 km. Predict how the number of cells changes when spacing is quartered. At 1 km spacing the width spans three nominal cells. At 250 m it spans twelve. Actual samples inside depend on grid alignment. To test resolution, refine again while retaining comparable physics, and compare width, peak w and track over the same period.
Practice questions
- How many nominal cells are across at 500 m spacing?
- Does a count of twelve prove the updraft is resolved?
- How should you compare simulated peak w across the runs?
Worked answers
Answer 1
3,000/500 = 6.
Answer 2
No. Compare the diagnosed structure and key outputs at finer spacings.
Answer 3
Use the same time window, physical feature, height range and output definition.
- 3,000/500 = 6.
- No. Compare the diagnosed structure and key outputs at finer spacings.
- Use the same time window, physical feature, height range and output definition.