Can two environments have the same STP and different ideal updraft speeds?
Two environments can share a fixed-layer STP while having different CAPE. The ideal parcel speed depends only on CAPE in TornadoSim’s simplified energy calculation.
Start with How do you build a two-factor supercell simulation experiment?.
| CAPE (J/kg) | SRH (m²/s²) | STP | Ideal speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1500 | 150 | 1 | 54.8 m/s |
| 3000 | 75 | 1 | 77.5 m/s |
Set up the experiment
Keep shear at 20 m/s and LCL at 1,000 m AGL. Before calculating, predict which combination has the larger theoretical speed and whether the index changes. The products of normalized CAPE and helicity are 1×1 and 2×0.5, both one. The theoretical speeds are √3000 and √6000 m/s. The square-root relation describes lossless parcel acceleration, so actual updrafts can differ.
Practice questions
- By what ratio did ideal speed change?
- At 750 J/kg, what SRH retains an index of one under the same assumptions?
- What happens if LCL rises to 1,500 m in both runs?
Worked answers
Answer 1
√2 ≈ 1.414.
Answer 2
CAPE factor is 0.5, so the helicity factor must be two and SRH must be 300 m²/s².
Answer 3
Both indices halve and the ideal speeds stay the same.
- √2 ≈ 1.414.
- CAPE factor is 0.5, so the helicity factor must be two and SRH must be 300 m²/s².
- Both indices halve and the ideal speeds stay the same.