Why do surface-based and elevated CAPE disagree on the same sounding?
CAPE depends on which parcel you lift. A near-surface parcel can remain too cool to develop positive buoyancy while a parcel drawn above a shallow inversion finds a buoyant layer in the same environment.
Start with CAPE integration practice with a three-level sounding.
| Parcel source | Prescribed positive layer | CAPE (J/kg) |
|---|---|---|
| Surface | None | 0 |
| Elevated above the inversion | 1.0 to 2.5 km AGL at +0.10 m/s² | 150 |
Set up the experiment
Use the same synthetic environmental sounding for both parcel choices. The example supplies idealized buoyancy profiles in height coordinates so you can isolate the integration. Use a single parcel at each source level with no averaging. Before calculating, predict which parcel has the larger positive integral. The surface profile has no positive area. The elevated parcel has +0.10 m/s² from 1.0 to 2.5 km AGL, giving 0.10 × 1,500 = 150 J/kg. These piecewise values approximate a profile and do not resolve its transitions.
Practice questions
- Keep the elevated layer thickness and halve its positive buoyancy. Recompute CAPE.
- Keep buoyancy at +0.10 m/s² and raise the top from 2.5 to 3.0 km AGL. Find CAPE.
- How would reporting just “CAPE = 150 J/kg” obscure this experiment?
Worked answers
Answer 1
0.05 × 1,500 = 75 J/kg.
Answer 2
The thickness is now 2,000 m, so CAPE is 200 J/kg.
Answer 3
It hides that 150 J/kg is associated with the elevated parcel. A surface-based diagnostic gives zero in the same example.
- 0.05 × 1,500 = 75 J/kg.
- The thickness is now 2,000 m, so CAPE is 200 J/kg.
- It hides that 150 J/kg is associated with the elevated parcel. A surface-based diagnostic gives zero in the same example.